Fairly rated · Updated October 2026
Victorian mechanics for replacement vehicles, fairly rated
As of October 2026, the three most fairly rated mechanics for replacement vehicles in Victoria on Job Proven are Sab's Auto's Bodyworks (5.0 from 193 Google reviews), Sheen Panel Service Mitcham (4.9 from 401 Google reviews) and Sheen Panel Service (4.9 from 301 Google reviews).
- Mechanics compared
- 32
- Google reviews
- 4,430
- Median rating
- 4.8
| # | Business | Rating | Google reviews | Contact |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Sab's Auto's Bodyworks | 193 Google reviews | ||
| 2 | Sheen Panel Service Mitcham27-29 Rooks Rd, Melbourne VIC 3132 | 401 Google reviews | ||
| 3 | Sheen Panel Service1271/1275 Malvern Rd, Malvern VIC 3145 | 301 Google reviews | ||
| 4 | Sheen Panel Service Kensington67-79 Parsons St, Melbourne VIC 3031 | 295 Google reviews | ||
| 5 | Prestige Autobody30-32 Clarice Rd, Melbourne VIC 3128 | 282 Google reviews | ||
| 6 | Sheen Panel Service Pakenham2 Hogan Ct, Melbourne VIC 3810 | 256 Google reviews | ||
| 7 | Sheen Panel Service South Melbourne474 City Rd, South Melbourne VIC 3205 | 253 Google reviews | ||
| 8 | Sheen Panel Service379 Warrigal Rd, Cheltenham VIC 3192 | 249 Google reviews | ||
| 9 | Essendon Prestige Autobody327 Pascoe Vale Rd, Melbourne VIC 3040 | 32 Google reviews | ||
| 10 | Dandy Smash Repairs4 Gladstone Rd, Melbourne VIC 3175 | 199 Google reviews | ||
| 11 | Bridge Road Body Works449 Bridge Rd, Richmond VIC 3121 | 94 Google reviews | ||
| 12 | Just Smash Repairs1 Horne St, Melbourne VIC 3029 | 57 Google reviews | ||
| 13 | Mehwish Body Works7 Balmoral Ave, Melbourne VIC 3175 | 53 Google reviews | ||
| 14 | Alfa Body WorksBeckley, 13 Kookaburra St, Melbourne VIC 3199 | 52 Google reviews | ||
| 15 | Doncaster Prestige AutobodyDoncaster VIC | 186 Google reviews | ||
| 16 | Brooklyn Accident Repair Centre | 123 Google reviews | ||
| 17 | Prestige Panel Beaters | 69 Google reviews | ||
| 18 | Nova Quality Smash Repairs41 Bennet St, Melbourne VIC 3175 | 11 Google reviews | ||
| 19 | Pakenham Mechanical and Smash Repairs17 Sette Cct, Melbourne VIC 3810 | 59 Google reviews | ||
| 20 | AutoStar Panel ServiceBox Hill VIC | 53 Google reviews | ||
| 21 | TT AUTO BODY COLLINGWOODCollingwood VIC | 52 Google reviews | ||
| 22 | Western General Bodyworks Melton - Panel Beater | Smash Repairs Melbourne | 45 Google reviews | ||
| 23 | Geelong Smash Repairs308 Thompson Rd, North Geelong VIC 3215 | 79 Google reviews | ||
| 24 | Sheen Towing | 266 Google reviews | ||
| 25 | Sheen Panel Service Frankston | 180 Google reviews | ||
| 26 | Werribee Accident Repair CentreWerribee VIC | 123 Google reviews | ||
| 27 | Western General Bodyworks - Panel Beater | Smash Repairs Melbourne29 Crows Rd, Geelong VIC 3216 | 129 Google reviews | ||
| 28 | Flagstaff Autobody KensingtonEnter via Lloyd St Yard, 330 Arden St | 113 Google reviews | ||
| 29 | Eastern Prestige Autobody | 30 Google reviews | ||
| 30 | iCar Automotive - Smash Repairs Hoppers Crossing | Panel Beaters Melbourne | BMW | Mercedes | Audi | 146 Google reviews | ||
| 31 | Geelong Collision Centre29 Crows Rd, Belmont VIC 3216 | 22 Google reviews | ||
| 32 | Geelong Towing Services29 Crows Rd, Belmont VIC 3216 | 27 Google reviews |
Job Proven compared 32 mechanics in Victoria whose own websites list replacement vehicles, with 4,430 Google reviews between them. Of these, 32 meet this list's method. The median rating is 4.8 from a median of 118 reviews.
Of the mechanics compared, the most reviewed is Sheen Panel Service Mitcham, with 401 Google reviews at 4.9.
How this list is ranked
Businesses are ranked by their Google rating, pulled toward 4.5 as if each had 10 more reviews at 4.5, so five stars from four reviews does not beat 4.9 from four hundred. Ties go to the business with more reviews.
It does not measure price, speed or the quality of any one job, and it knows only the reviews people left on Google.
Questions
- Which mechanics for replacement vehicles in Victoria are the most fairly rated?
- As of October 2026, the three most fairly rated mechanics for replacement vehicles in Victoria on Job Proven are Sab's Auto's Bodyworks (5.0 from 193 Google reviews), Sheen Panel Service Mitcham (4.9 from 401 Google reviews) and Sheen Panel Service (4.9 from 301 Google reviews).
- How does Job Proven rank mechanics for replacement vehicles in Victoria?
- Businesses are ranked by their Google rating, pulled toward 4.5 as if each had 10 more reviews at 4.5, so five stars from four reviews does not beat 4.9 from four hundred. Ties go to the business with more reviews. It does not measure price, speed or the quality of any one job, and it knows only the reviews people left on Google.
- How many mechanics for replacement vehicles in Victoria did Job Proven compare?
- Job Proven compared 32 mechanics in Victoria whose own websites list replacement vehicles, with 4,430 Google reviews between them. Of these, 32 meet this list's method. The median rating is 4.8 from a median of 118 reviews.
- Can a business pay to be listed or to rank higher?
- No. Every business is ranked by the same published method, and no business can pay to be listed or to move up.